The problem with book posts is that very often there are books about which I have nothing to say. They may have been disappointments. I may have enjoyed reading the books, and even felt them to be useful, but still not found them so interesting that I wish to write a blog post. The question then becomes whether or a not a list of books is worth maintaining on this blog. I have a list of books I've read elsewhere, but if this blog is a place to review what is actually capturing my fancy or on my mind, book lists may prove to be useless.
I "read" eight books in April. The word read is in quotation marks because I listened to two of those books on Audible while I was working on embroidery or other needlework. I spent over 60-hours on embroidery in late March and early April, more than enough time to listen to two volumes of the Robert Jordan Wheel of Time series. I enjoyed them. Do I have anything to say about them? No. Do I consider listening to books the same as reading? The answer to that really depends on the type of book and the circumstances, but generally I would say "not really", although listening to books simply to gather information, or for distraction or entertainment can be a profitable pursuit. Do audio books count as books or not? I remain undecided, but I am leaning toward yes, although I recognize that I do not process things I hear in the same way I process the written word. A good book, a highly worthwhile book, may require two readings to fully absorb, and there is no reason why that first, lay-of-the-land reading could not be in the form of an audiobook. Of course there are a lot of books that are only worth a quick once-through, perhaps even a skim. And the number of books that really hold up to deep reading, books from which more is revealed with each pass, are few. Despite this, all books we read, whether for knowledge or escape, contribute to who we are and what we think and believe.
Here I am back at the list. To continue from my last post:
20. Caesar: Life of A Collosus, Adrian Goldsworthy (biography)
21. Troubled: A Memoir of Foster Care, Family and Social Class, Rob Henderson (memoir)
22. The Heaven and Earth Grocery Store, James McBride (novel)
23. The Girl Giant, Kristen den Hartog (novel)
24. The Vulnerables, Sigrid Nunez (novel)
25. Winter's Heart, Robert Jordan (novel)
26. The Color of Water, James McBride (memoir)
27. Crossroads of Twilight, Robert Jordan (novel)
The first two books, Caesar and Troubled, were both fabulous and thought-provoking although for very different reasons. Most of Caesar was read in March although I finished at the beginning of April. It reminded me of a lot of things about Rome I once knew but which had slipped to the back of my memory, and I learned much about both Julius Caesar and Rome. This was a fabulous informative, well-written, compelling biography. I do, however, understand that I need to read the book again in order to fully absorb it.
Troubled was also fascinating and thought provoking, a faster read but well worth thinking about. The book is well written, but the prose is a bit terse and guarded, no grandiose memoirist Henderson. Still the story was both sad and thought-provoking. I may disagree with some of Henderson's theories and agree with others, but agreement with the author's premise is never a prerequisite for liking a book -- I would simply expect the author to make me think, and Henderson does that. I'm not convinced the book deserves the kind of focused rereading that Adrian Goldsworthy's book does, nor do I find it as complex, but I do need to engage with the book a little further if for no other reason than to better formulate my own response.
Most of the fiction was read for entertainment reasons. As mentioned above, I listened to the two novels by Robert Jordan. I am enjoying the series, and it is actually rather complex and intellectually interesting. I will probably read in its physical form some day.
I read James McBride's The Heaven and Earth Grocery Store a second time, for my book club, and I although I enjoyed thoroughly, very little new was revealed. It seems to straddle the line between commercial and literary fiction, with some literary aspects but the basic formula and neatly resolved ending that usually comes with commercial fiction. There is probably a name for this category, I call it "book club" fiction. Reading the novel again did prompt me to read McBride's memoir of his mother The Color of Water, because on this reading of the novel it struck me that a number of the characters and plot points were based on McBride's own family story. That impression was confirmed. I suspect the novel could only have evolved out of what began with the memoir, and yet I still find the novel more fully realized and interesting.
Of the two remaining novels, Kristen den Hartog's novel The Girl Giant, was well written, thoughtful and somewhat engaging in a rather quiet way, but I never really connected with it. In fact I felt it rather bland, but that is all about me.
The novel I did love was Sigrid Nunez's novel The Vulnerables.. This was definitely a literary novel, and in many ways a "small" novel, taking place over a short period of time in the life of a single character. I found that a great deal of Nunez's auto-fictional musings on art, life, literature engaging and compelling. In fact a lot of the passages I copied out in my journal reference literature, from Dickens to Brecht, not so much directly, but the way the author uses literature as an internal framework for the journeys that encompass a life. Due to its literary nature, there are no answers here, no pat conclusions. It is a book I will pick up again and again to read the odd passage.