I want to get caught up with 2023 before January ends, which means there will be no review of the remaining books on last year's list. Not that I am inclined toward toward such a task. I do, however, want to think about my favorite novels, and so I shall.
I've always avoided the arbitrariness of best lists, but somehow now that is exactly what I wish to embrace. This blog, after all, is extremely arbitrary, wrapped as it is in my choices, my thoughts, my interests.
In December a member of my book club proposed that we each think of our favorite book from the year. It seemed that, for the most part, each of us chose a different book and I found the discussion fascinating. My own favorite book was not the book I had initially chosen for book club discussion, so let's start this post there.
Small Things Like These, by Claire Keegan would have been on my "favorite books" list from 2022, had I made one. But my book club read it in 2023, and it was my favorite book of our selections. It is a book that holds up to subsequent readings, and reveals more of itself with each encounter. But I don't think my thoughts have changed significantly since I reviewed it in 2022. (here). I read this for both of my book clubs this year, and it would be my favorite selection from each, although since I had read it the previous year as well, I would only put it in fifth place among this year's favorites.
In position number 4 on my list would be Sheena Patel's novel I'm a Fan. I thoroughly enjoyed reading this novel and I found it entertaining, challenging, and thought-provoking. The story and the experiences of the protagonist are completely outside my experience, completely outside the possibility of anything I would consider. Perhaps this is part of what elevates the novel because the protagonist is nothing like me and yet she becomes completely sympathetic and at times even understandable. I feel like the author is helping me with insight into the inner world of a girl I would otherwise never bother to understand, who in a way lives in a world that is nothing like mine, even though it is the same world. I would still read this again and, as I stated in my previous review, I would still love to discuss this book with someone else or perhaps even in a multi-generational small group. I don't have much beyond that review to say, but ideas and images from that novel still arise regularly in my thoughts.
Number three on the list is completely different. Although Patel's book is deeply artistic, intellectual, interior and polemical, Abraham Verghese's novel The Covenant of Water is a large, thoroughly enjoyable and engaging, family drama set among the Christian community in Kerala, India. I read this twice, once in hardcover, and again listening to the audiobook on Audible, where it is narrated by the author. Both formats are worthwhile. This is the kind of novel that I can get lost in and am reluctant to put down, a book a friend once referred to as the kind of book you "read, read" meaning the kind of book in which she would completely lose herself in the story. Here, this novel, yes.
All of Verghese's novels have some medical component, or at least all the novels I've read, and this no exception. I find that the medicine is artfully woven into the warp and weft of the story, and that even the parts I don't care about, or the characters about whom I am initially doubtful, all become essential to the makeup of the fabric of the story. This is a novel to savor.
And just like that I'm to number two, the runner up. That would be This Other Eden by Paul Harding. This novel was nominated for the Booker prize, and it did make the short list, but I didn't read it until after the winner was announced. (It did not win). But I've already stated I wasn't somehow engaged in Booker-mania this year, and that is okay. I did however thoroughly enjoy this book.
The novel is inspired by the true story of Malaga Island, which was once the home of a mixed-race fishing community, until the state of Maine evicted the residents. But Harding has firmly held that although he was inspired by the true story, he has made no attempt to tell the specifics of that story. Instead we get a luminous story of well-drawn, all-too-human characters told in poetically mesmerizing prose. Even though I knew how the story must end, I felt compelled to to dive further and further into this deeply haunting novel. The story told is as much a story of a community, how they relate amongst themselves, as well as their position relative to the society as a whole. At times allegorical, it is an exploration of humanity, wisdom, ignorance, power and loss. The writing is fluid, imaginative, metaphorical. Biblical references abound and this reader found them entertaining, but the author is not particularly heavy-handed about driving home lessons.
The character of Matthew Diamond, a retired schoolteacher who strives to help the residents of Apple Island, while at the same time battling his own aversions to their mixed race heritage, is particularly compelling. Diamond brought to mind both the work and the life of the theologian Karl Barth, even before I knew the author modeled Diamond in part on Barth.
There are also strong correlations to The Colony, by Audrey Magee, another novel about the incursion into and destruction of a unique and "lost" way of life, partially at the hands of well-meaning but misguided souls who only wish to "help". The side story where young Ethan, sent away from the island, falls in love with Bridget, a young Irish serving girl, herself from a small isolated island community, seals both the link to Magee's novel and the universality of the themes that are playing out. This book satisfies both my love of a good story, and my intellectual leanings. It is also a book that I am sure will reveal itself further with future readings.
Which leads me to my first choice, The North Shore, by Ben Tufnell, a novel all about liminality and metamorphosis. I do realize that this means it is not, perhaps, most people's cup of tea, but it is perfectly mine. I am not certain that I have more to say about this novel above what I wrote in my previous review, here.. I found it an absolutely fascinating novel, a novel which I pick up occasionally to reread selected passages. Just thinking about it makes me want to read it again, but I can admit that this is a novel in which I cannot separate the story from the intellectual process that it evokes. It very much feels to me like a novel almost attempting to form its own metamorphosis, of blurring the boundaries between art, and life, word, experience, and how we know what we know.