Driving home from Florida, we stopped in North Carolina and bought apples. We had been discussing applesauce, and although I hadn't actually made applesauce since I left New York state, I was game, so we split a half-bushel of Cortlands.
A large part of yesterday's general busywork revolved around tasks in the kitchen. I made a pot of chicken soup, which was pretty much a guaranteed success. Then there were my experiments: applesauce and lemon meringue pie.
I ended up with a little over 3 quarts of applesauce with enough leftover apples for a pie. I am freezing the pie filling for future use, as I plan some experimentation to perfect my gluten-free crust. The applesauce is being frozen in pint jars, although I only had 3 on hand, so the rest of the applesauce is in a bowl in the refrigerator, waiting for me to pick up more jars this afternoon. That is, if I manage to avoid eating it before I get the jars in the house. I hadn't forgotten how superior homemade applesauce is to the store-bought stuff, but I guess I had forgotten how utterly delicious it really is.
Even using only one kind of apple in this batch, I was impressed with the depth of flavor in the finished applesauce as well as the subtle sweetness (I added spices but no sugar). My applesauce is darker than some because I simply wash and quarter the apples before cooking. I am a lazy cook and I'd rather run the cooked apples through a food mill than peel and core the apples, especially considering that these apples were on the small side. The skins enhance the flavor and even though my apple skins were not deeply red, they still added depth to the color of the finished applesauce.
The lemon meringue pie was a less successful experiment. I used to make this pie all the time but I had never really written down the adaptations I had made to the original recipe to make it successfully gluten-free. I knew I used a cookie crumb crust, made from ready-made gingersnaps, but I had not written down the proportions and a few other details. I was hoping to make the pie again this weekend for a dinner party, but thought a test run was in order since it has been about 4 or 5 years since I have made this pie.
The pie looked beautiful although I knew there were a few issues even before the first cut was made. First of all, I had the proportion of butter to cookie crumb wrong. Butter melted all over the oven while the pie baked and made a mess. The resulting cookie crust was too dense and a little oily, although the flavor was good. Since the dripping butter made a lot of smoke, I took the pie out of the oven too early. This wasn't evident until I cut into it, when it became apparent that the center was still just a touch too soft; another 5 to 8 minutes of cooking time would do the trick.
The bigger problem is my own ambivalence. It is not really a question of taste, the lemon part of the pie is nicely tart and lemony and it sets off the sweetness of the meringue nicely. Even so, the pie was just too sweet for me. This surprised me. I've been plagued with a sweet tooth all my life. It was a good thing my mother didn't keep sweets and desserts in the house when I was a child because I would have been sneaking around stealing them. I always had a stash of candy under my bed. In 7th grade I took my lunch money and bought a hot-fudge sunday for lunch every day for at least half the year. Even 4 years ago, although I ate sweets rarely, once I started I couldn't stop.
Now, it is not that I never crave something sweet; I do, but a small piece was enough. A small piece of this pie however was too much. I always assumed I would bake things for others if not for myself. Now I wonder. I wonder even if I want to make dessert for Sunday. Perhaps store-bought cookes and ice cream would be enough. Personally I would probably prefer some cheese, a little fruit, and some coffee or dessert wine. I wonder how that would go over. What is the worst thing that could happen? People would think I am weird and not come back?
I think I need to reconsider my menu.